The couple said on Tilley's podcast that it was "hilarious" how they didn't realize their engagement was at a nudist beach

Tilley, who was the runner-up on the 19th season of the dating series, when Chris Soules starred, and returned in the following one to romance Ben Higgins before being eliminated ahead of hometown dates, is engaged to pop singer and actress Hayley Kiyoko.

"Bachelor" alum Becca Tilley and singer Hayley Kiyoko announced their engagement on social media following Kiyoko's proposal.